Echo vs Sparkle Comparison — May 23, 2026

Echo: UCSF_ECHO_20260523.csv (6143 providers) · Sparkle: physicians-sparkle-20260523.csv (6162 providers) · Generated: May 24, 2026 6:40 PM CSV← Back to index
✓ 1 Eligible to publish − 4 In Echo, not eligible ✗ 21 Published, not in Echo (7 strategic) • 2 Unpublished, not in Echo ⚠ 1 NPI discrepancy

➕ In Echo, Not in Sparkle — Eligible to Publish (1)

Has a scheduling template and is not exclusively Entity: CIP (unless Subgroup UCNAC).

NPINamePrimary SpecialtyTypeRecord StatusEntitiesSubgroups
1124124540William KoehnePediatricsPhysicianActiveCCCFMG

• In Echo, Not in Sparkle — Not Eligible (4)

Fails one or more publishing rules.

NPINamePrimary SpecialtyTypeEntitiesSubgroupsWhy ineligible
1083621379Marie PresidentInternal MedicinePhysicianCCCFMGno scheduling template
1447327572Elizabeth MoyObstetrics & GynecologyPhysicianCCCFMGno scheduling template
1467230524Aqueelah TillmanCertified Nurse MidwifeMidwifeCCCFMGno scheduling template
1679641658Laurie GreenObstetrics & GynecologyPhysicianCCCFMGno scheduling template

➖ In Sparkle, Not in Echo — Published (21)

Currently live on the website but absent from Echo. Potential candidates to unpublish. 7 flagged — matched to a strategic service line; verify before unpublishing.

NPINameTaxonomy SpecialtiesStrategistWebsite
1457501439Obstetrics and GynecologyVanessa HaleyUCSF Health
1679349625Family MedicineStacy MoweryUCSF Health
1720330152Physical Therapy, NeurorehabilitationJason KnightUCSF Health
1770523771Maternal and Fetal MedicineVanessa HaleyUCSF Health
1790869196Obstetrics and GynecologyVanessa HaleyUCSF Health
1871145292Physical Therapy, Spine MedicineStacy MoweryUCSF Health
1942556451Speech-Language Pathology, NeurorehabilitationJason KnightUCSF Health
1114955820Physical Therapy—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1194048363Physical Therapy—UCSF Health
1235778499Physical Therapy—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1285926675Physical Therapy—UCSF Health
1396923926Pediatric Sports Medicine—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1437294360Audiology—Any Website
1447596887Physical Therapy—UCSF Health
1457601452Physical Therapy—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1518203959Physical Therapy—UCSF Health
1851315485Physical Therapy—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1861973406Physical Therapy—UCSF Health
1891240172Physical Therapy—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1982151833Audiology—UCSF Health
99929443827Non-Operative Pediatric Orthopedics—UCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals

• In Sparkle, Not in Echo — Unpublished (2)

In Sparkle but not in Echo, and already unpublished. Lower urgency.

NPINameTaxonomy SpecialtiesPublishing StatusWebsite
1639355332Pediatric AudiologyUnpublishedUCSF Benioff Children's Hospitals
1831180132UnpublishedAny Website

⚠ NPI Discrepancy (1)

In Sparkle but matched to an Echo record via Corporate ID — the NPI on the Sparkle record is missing or malformed. The provider exists in both systems; the NPI data needs cleanup.

Sparkle NPINameTaxonomy SpecialtiesPublishing StatusMatched Echo Corporate ID
n/aSocial WorkPublished023640584